Roasting the Perfect Cup of Joe
Published in BackHome May/June 2007
Whether with a hot mug of instant Nescafe or steaming cup of
cappuccino, people across the globe start their mornings with coffee.
Today a growing number of caffeine fans are not only brewing but also
roasting and grinding their own beans. To these connoisseurs, home
coffee roasting has become synonymous with the perfect cup of joe.
“Home roasting is in its infancy but for the first time it’s a
rapidly expanding niche in the coffee market,” says James Cameron,
owner of the Wisconsin-based, green bean supply company U-Roast-Em and
a founding member of the Specialty Coffee Association of America, the
trade association setting the standards for growing, roasting and
brewing gourmet, or specialty, coffee.
Cameron estimates that in 2005 alone the number of home roasters in
the U.S. multiplied more than 10 times. A former commercial roaster, he
attributes this boom in home roasting to the high prices and low
quality of commercially, mass-produced roasted beans and the increasing
desire on the part of the coffee consumer for quality and freshness.
Home roaster Jeff Caskey can attest to this yearning for a fresh,
flavorful hot beverage. His venture into roasting began over three
years ago with the search for a new coffee maker and a better pot of
coffee. After perusing several home roasting websites and reading
coffee expert Kenneth Davids’ seminal book, Home Coffee Roasting: Romance and Revival, Caskey replaced not just his coffee maker but his entire source of coffee.
“A lot of coffee shops don’t roast their own coffee. Those that do
usually don’t date their beans so you could be buying stale, old
coffee,” says the systems analyst who lives and works in suburban
Philadelphia.
As Caskey points out, left untouched, the pale green coffee bean
remains fresh for one to two years. Yet, once it is roasted, it begins
to relinquish its delicate oils and, therefore, flavor within a few
days. After a week the roasted bean will have lost its distinct flavor,
aroma and freshness. Grind and brew a batch of beans like this and you
end up with a lackluster pot of coffee.
Pre-ground beans fare even worse. Grinding instantly releases the
beans’ oils and speeds up the deterioration process. It should be done
only minutes prior to brewing, not hours or days before consuming. Walk
out of a coffee shop after paying $9 to $13 for a pound of ground
coffee and you depart with a costly, increasingly bland beverage in
hand.
Along with desiring a fresh cup of coffee, Caskey, like many home
roasters, was lured by the prospect of increased flavor and complexity
in each pot. “A lot of commercial roasters roast to a dark oil where
all the flavors of the bean have burnt off. You no longer taste the
flavor or the differences within beans. With home roasting there is no
bitterness or burnt taste, so you can add more ground coffee per cup,”
he says.
As well as selecting the type and origin of their beans, from Costa
Rica to Zimbabwe, home roasters choose the level of roasting from the
darkest “Spanish” roast to the light, dry “cinnamon.” Each batch made,
every cup drunk is tailored to their palate and preferences.
Blending, or the combining of beans from different crops or regions,
allows roasters to play with flavors and create distinctive coffees. In
blending they also mix inexpensive with costlier beans, thus saving
money and extending their premium bean supply. Such is the case with
the Hawaiian Kona blend where the distinct flavors of the high end
Hawaiian Kona are combined with a less pricey, more subtle bean.
Even without blending beans, these coffee aficionados end up saving
money, spending half of what their non-roasting counterparts hand over
for a pound of coffee. Most of James Cameron’s U-Roast-Em customers buy
beans in five pound increments with their cost per pound averaging
around $5. At Sweet Maria’s, a popular California-based, online
supplier of green beans, roasting equipment, and tips, novices can buy
both regular and organic beans from $5 a pound.
By belonging to a coffee buying cooperative, roasters like Caskey
save even more. This non-profit cooperative, in Caskey’s words, “cuts
out the middle man.” Members across the country pool their resources
and purchase beans in bulk directly from the importers and, in some
cases, the producers.
Once a shipment arrives at port, co-op volunteers fetch the bulging
burlap bags at the docks then divvy up and ship the coffee to the
members. Through a cooperative Caskey pays as little as $3 a pound for
Sumatran, Yemen, and Guatemalan beans.
Because green beans store so well, many roaster create cellars of
their favorite coffees, stockpiling their beans according to region,
such as Costa Rica or Kenya, and flavor profile, such as Blue Mountain
or Kona. As with avid wine drinkers, they can pair their beverage with
specific foods, occasions, or moods.
To store their beans properly and safely, roasters place them in a
cool, dark, and dry location. Ideally, the beans should be kept inside
burlap bags with drawstring closures. These bags allow them to breathe
yet protect them from dust, pests, and other nuisances.
Beyond the freshness, flavor, and cost-saving factors, many are
drawn into home roasting for socially conscious reasons. Theirs is a
coffee both good in taste and intentions. Those disheartened by the
dearth of fair trade beans sold in coffee shops and supermarkets can
have green, fair trade beans delivered right to their doors. They can
also buy from bean suppliers who support the international non-profits
such as the organization Coffee Kids. Founded in 1988 by Rhode Island
coffee roaster and retailer Bill Fishbein, Coffee Kids’ creates
educational, training and health care programs for Latin American
coffee farmers and their families.
Those concerned about the environmental impact of coffee farming
have more options through home roasting as well. When buying green
beans, they can select organic, shade grown and family-farm or
cooperative produced beans over the profusion sold by enormous,
wildlife and forest-depleting agri-businesses. Shade grown coffee farms
intersperse the small coffee trees among other crops and taller trees,
creating shelter for animals and migrating birds. Common in Central
America, this growing method also reduces soil erosion and
deforestation.
Just as there are a variety of reasons for roasting, there is also
an array of ways to roast. A few purists prefer to follow the methods
of the past and roast their beans in a skillet on their stoves or over
a small, well-ventilated fire. Until the advent of commercial roasters
in the mid 19th century, this was how roasting was done.
Those employing a skillet need a large pan with matching lid, an
oven thermometer, and heavy oven mitts. They begin by putting the pan
over a flame and placing the thermometer inside the pan. Covering both
with the lid, they heat the skillet to 500˚ F.
Desired temperature reached, the roasters remove the thermometer and
pour in approximately nine ounces of green beans. They then put the lid
back on, grasp the pan’s handle, and start shaking it. They move the
pan over the heat source, lifting the lid and checking the beans’
progress periodically, until all have turned a deep brown. This takes
about 10 minutes.
Some opt for more ingenious yet equally inexpensive means, such as
roasting in an air popcorn popper or in a metal drum on an outdoor
grille’s rotisserie. Those utilizing the air popcorn popper should
select one with side air vents in its popping chamber and a chute on
its plastic lid for blowing out the chaff, or skin, of the roasted
bean. Both reduce the risk of the chaff igniting. The West Bend Poppery
II is a perennial favorite.
With an air popper roasters pour in the same amount of beans as
recommended for popcorn, between two-thirds and three-quarters of a
cup. They then attach the popper’s lid, slide a bowl beneath the lid’s
chute, flip on the popper and watch the beans roast. In less than 10
minutes the bowl will contain bits of chaff, the beans will be aromatic
and brown, and the batch will be done.
Others select more conventional approaches, using commercially sold
fluid bed roasters, which, like the popcorn popper, apply hot air, or
radiant drum roasters where radiant heat does the roasting. As with any
method, these roasters should be placed in a well-ventilated area, such
as near a window, kitchen vent, or exhaust fan.
Among the non-roasting community the process raising the most
eyebrows has to be the dog bowl. Great at conducting and retaining
heat, dog bowls have proved to be a cheap, easy vessel for roasting
small as well as large batches of beans.
After measuring 1 ½ cups of green, decaffeinated beans on his
digital kitchen scale, Jeff Caskey drops them into a large, stainless
steel dog bowl that he has placed inside his stone fireplace. Grabbing
his red heat gun and a singed wooden spoon, he flips on a digital
timer, aims the gun at the bowl and, turning on the heat, begins to
stir the green beans.
Within minutes the rooms fills with the rich scent of coffee. The
beans transform in color from pale green to yellow then light brown.
Puffs of smoke rise from the bowl and waft up the fireplace chimney.
After 10 minutes of continually stirring and applying heat, Caskey
hears the “first crack,” the cracking noise indicating that the beans
are well along in the roasting process. At this point the beans have
swelled in size. Their oils have emerged, creating a glossy sheen on
the darkening beans.
Three to five minutes later Caskey hears the “second crack,” the
sign for him that the beans are done. He shuts off the heat gun and
timer and, reaching for a long-handled colander, dumps the beans into
the strainer. Wanting to cool off the beans before storing them, he
flicks on a large box fan that he has situated on the hearth and,
holding the colander in front of the fan, agitates the beans until they
have cooled. He then pours the beans into a glass canister that he
places inside his kitchen cupboard.
In 15 minutes Caskey has roasted enough beans to last him a week.
Had he used his modified air popcorn popper, the process would have
taken even less time, about 10 minutes.
The best part about Caskey’s weekly routine is not the speed but the
outcoutcome. A cup of his Panama Royal Select SWP decaf is delight for
the drinker. Smooth, clear, and distinct in taste, it possesses not a
hint of bitterness. Home roasted beans do truly make a perfect cup of
coffee.